The Ph.D. in Creativity
We’re doing something no one else has done—we’ve radically reconceived the Ph.D. degree based on the premise that creative thinking lies at the heart of innovation in all fields.
A low-residency degree for advanced interdisciplinary research in the arts, humanities, sciences, and social sciences. This pioneering Ph.D. offers unique features not found elsewhere: intensive immersion in creative thinking, cross-disciplinary workshops for dissertation development, and professionally accomplished advisors from outside the university whose selection is tailored to best serve each unique dissertation.
All Ph.D. programs require a dissertation that makes “an original contribution to knowledge.” Yet after steeping the candidate in the existing literature and methods, they offer no guidance on how to move beyond them. So as George Bernard Shaw famously wrote "progress depends on the unreasonable man”1 who changes rather than accepts established practices. At the University of the Arts, our Ph.D. is about fundamentally changing the way our students think. We intend to use a deep immersion in the intuitive practices of the arts to seed a more creative working practice in students who come already prepared with the conventional methods and knowledge of whatever fields they work in. We seek students who have already achieved a professional mastery in some discipline and we prepare them to go to another level. We show them how to be open to finding that moment when ideas that didn’t seem to have anything to do with one another suddenly come together to ask or answer a question, create a solution to a problem, produce a new invention. The complexity of problem solving in the arts, in their deliberate embrace of intuition, differs from scientific methods. The statistical odds of a scientist winning a Nobel Prize triples if he or she has an avocational practice in the arts.2 This immersion in the arts can teach a practitioner in any field – in science, in medicine, in business, engineering, health care, the social sciences, innovators in the non-profit world, and even in the arts – to think more creatively. Business entrepreneurs need to “think out of the box”; musicians need to do more than master the score.
The statistical odds of a scientist winning a Nobel Prize triples if he or she has an avocational practice in the arts.
Although the Ph.D. is increasingly the gateway for high level careers outside academia, most universities require it for full academic rank. We intend to prepare our graduates for a more creative approach to whatever path they take and expect industries as well as the academy to set a premium on our degree. By redefining the underlying approach to their practice, our graduates return to the work world equipped with deep expertise in an area they helped to define and in which they are strongly invested, while also deeply embracing the creative process. They gain singular expertise in a field they create for themselves; consequently, their future work will fit them better for a career that lines up with their real interests. As our graduates succeed in public life, this University of the Arts degree will also further a broader understanding of the centrality of the arts in all education, at every level.
The Ph.D. and the Immersion in Creative Thinking
We offer two connected but separable programs: the Ph.D. in Creativity and the Immersion in Creative Thinking. The Immersion can be taken separately or as the prerequisite to the Ph.D.
The Three Year Ph.D
Most six-year Ph.D. programs give students a thorough training in the methods and base knowledge in a field and then administer a qualifying examination to pass the student on to the dissertation stage of their work. Most offer an M.A. or M.S. degree at this stage. Many of those students go to work in their field at this point without going on to write a Ph.D. dissertation. Others go straight into the dissertation. Our program looks at that M.A. or other training received from another institution, together with an applicant’s work experience and their dissertation proposal in evaluating them to enter our dissertation-only Ph.D.
By reforming the underlying approach to their practice, our graduates return to the work world equipped with deep expertise in an area they themselves helped to define.
The Two Week Immersion in Creative Problem Solving
The arts offer the most consciously developed disciplines of non-linear and integrative thinking. But all transformative work – even in technology, science, and social science – depend upon intuition and non-linear thought just as the arts and humanities do, whether this is acknowledged or not. Contemporary work in neuroscience demonstrates that “cold logic,” devoid of a dynamic engagement with the emotional centers in the brain, doesn’t work.3 We need the rigors of the scientific method and the data base of knowledge in the disciplines. Yet to take innovation to another level we also need to transcend the hierarchies of conventional training. The new Ph.D. at the University of the Arts begins with creativity itself; creative thinking is in the DNA of our faculty and no university is better equipped to teach it. In addition, Philadelphia offers a brilliant array of creative activity. This program commences in mid-June each year with a two-week residency. Students will be immersed in a curated sequence of arts experiences for an intense course in creativity. These experiences differ from simply spectating as a consumer of the arts by engaging the student as a participant in each activity. Interspersed with this Immersion will be 4 days of methods seminars which will open students to both the contingency and possibilities of all approaches to research. Additionally, students will begin to workshop their individual Ph.D. projects during this perspective-expanding residency with support and critique from their cohort and the Program Director. Taken all together this intensive 14 days will promote a more creative framing of the dissertation research project and expand the student’s approach to problem solving more broadly.
The methods seminars prepare students to take greatest advantage of the arts immersion in breaking down the hierarchies of conventional trainings as they structure their projects. The intensive immersion in these often baffling encounters with creative problem solving in the arts coincides with feedback from their peers in the framing of the students’ dissertations. Since each cohort will come from a range of disciplines, candidates are forced to jettison disciplinary jargon to make their projects comprehensible to one another. Students may elect to take this two-week immersion course and not proceed to the Ph.D. with us. The admissions committee will also view each student’s performance in the immersion course as a final review of the student’s eligibility to proceed to the dissertation stage.
All transformative work – even in technology, science, and social science – depend upon intuition and non-linear thought.
The Ph.D. Dissertation or Project
The Ph.D. in Creativity at the University of the Arts is a research-based Ph.D. Each cohort of students will meet to workshop their dissertations during the first summer residency, as they frame the concept of their research. They meet again over a long weekend the following January, when they have substantial research behind them. Finally, they confer again the following summer as they enter the final stages of research and begin writing in the second year. We strongly encourage completion within three years.
On the Oxford model, we only accept students with a high degree of professional proficiency into the program and we focus on the production of a creative, interdisciplinary dissertation or other Ph.D. project. The preliminary studies required to qualify establish a base of disciplinary mastery in advance, as signified by the M.D., M.A., M.B.A., M.F.A., L.L.B. and M.Phil degrees, for example, or by equivalent experience in social services or non-profits or other background that prepares a student to begin at a dissertation level. The Ph.D. project is typically a written dissertation, however it may also take other forms of equivalent depth so long as the final work may be publicly shared and the dissertation committee is satisfied by the depth of research and thought. The public presentation in some form is a final requirement. The thesis, if written, would normally be between 30,000 and 50,000 words or the equivalent as approved by the individual’s committee; research projects in science, economics, or other disciplines in which a book length dissertation is not normal, will conform to the standards in those fields, which may be an online article or articles of sufficient merit to earn the degree. Students will present their work on a monthly basis to their committee and defend their theses in June of their third year, unless an extension is approved by their committee.
Most academic Ph.D. programs in the United States take half a dozen years or more to complete. Usually, the foundational preparation that might be completed in an M.A. or M.Phil program is absorbed into the Ph.D., often dispensing with the master’s degree. The Ph.D. at the University of the Arts assumes that M.A.-level work and experience in the field is already reached by our applicants before applying to our program, which is a dissertation-level program only. In nearly all Ph.D. programs candidates at this level focus on their dissertations, often while doing research independently for extended periods; the most profound teaching takes place in all Ph.D. programs in the individual interaction of the student with the Ph.D. advisor. Our program allows a student to continue working in a job so long as they can set aside time to work on their Ph.D. project; it does not require residency over most of the research and writing time. This is not unusual. But in our program we have several advisors for each dissertation, they are more specifically suited to the project, and they are more actively involved than in most residential programs, which is what makes it possible to complete the degree in three years.
…a committee of advisors tailored to their project…
Short Term Courses
In mid-June of the first year, students will come to the University of the Arts for a two-week intensive residency. They will need to prepare a list of readings before they arrive. When their cohort reconvenes in January and then again in the second summer of the program, there will also be challenging short term seminars in interdisciplinary topics designed specifically for them to reinforce their creative work.
The great power of the project is because it is absolutely irrational. This is the idea of the project, that the project put in doubt all the values.4
The Origins of this Program
David Yager and Jonathan Fineberg met in 2015 at a conference on cross-disciplinary thinking in art and science sponsored by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (part of the National Academies Keck Futures Initiative). Well known for his pathfinding work in medicine and art, the academies had asked David Yager to serve on the steering committee. The organizers asked Jonathan Fineberg to speak about his new book Modern Art at the Border of Mind and Brain which crosses psychoanalysis and neuroscience with art criticism for a fresh perspective on creative thinking. At this conference, Jonathan and David began a conversation that led to their collaboration in creating this radically reconceived Ph.D. On the premise that creative thinking lay at the heart of innovation in all fields, beginning the degree with an intensive focus on creative thinking made sense and starting in an art school, regardless of the fields of research, seemed appropriate.
The Ph.D. program is pending approval by the Middle States Commission on Higher Education.
- “The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.” George Bernard Shaw, Maxims for Revolutionists, in Man and Superman (1903), (Baltimore MD: Penguin Books, 1952), 267.
- See Adam Grant, Originals (N.Y.: Viking, 2016); based on the study by Robert Root-Bernstein et al, Journal of Psychology of Science and Technology, volume 1, number 2, 2008. Springer Publishing Co., DOI: 10.1891/1939-7054.1.2.51.
- Antonio Damasio’s book Descartes’s Error is one of many scientific contributions that point to this conclusion. See also Semir Zeki, Splendors and Miseries of the Brain, and Jonathan Fineberg, Modern Art at the Border of Mind and Brain
- Christo, conversation with the author, 1983, cited in Jonathan Fineberg, "Meaning and Being in Christo's Surrounded Islands," in Christo: Surrounded Islands (Harry N. Abrams Inc.: N.Y., 1986), 27.
The Advisory Council is comprised of distinguished professionals across diverse disciplines whose knowledge and expertise has contributed to the formation of this program. They will assist in the recommendation and selection of outside advisors to serve each dissertation.
President, University of the Arts, ex officio
Professor of Physics, Electrical and Computer Engineering, and Materials Science and Engineering and former Provost, Boston University.
Sohaib and Sara Abbasi Professor of Computer Science, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.
Author, television and record producer, founder of Funny Garbage and The Red Organization, N.Y.
Artist, NY. Creator, with Jeanne-Claude, of such temporary art projects as The Gates (NYC), Running Fence, Wrapped Reichstag, and The Mastaba, Abu Dhabi (currently in process).
Artist and entrepreneur, Beijing. Associated with Cynical Realism in the 1990s, Fang is a leading vanguard artist. He is also a founder of the National Archives of Contemporary Art.
President of the Dedalus Foundation and Distinguished Professor Emeritus of Art and Art History at Brooklyn College and the Graduate Center of the City University of New York.
Henry Louis Gates, Jr.
Alphonse Fletcher University Professor and Director of the Hutchins Center for African and African American Research at Harvard University. Recipient of the MacArthur “genius” award as well as an Emmy and a Peabody Award for his television series, The African Americans: Many Rivers to Cross.
Internationally known pianist, scholar and recording artist, who has received a lifetime achievement award from the Humboldt Foundation. A leading authority on Beethoven, he has published a dozen books, including Beethoven, The Creative Process in Music from Mozart to Kurtag and studies of Mozart and Wagner.
Artist, NY. A pioneer, with Ilya Kabakov, of installation art, with recent retrospectives at the Guggenhiem Museum in N.Y., The Hirshhorn Museum in Washington, and the Tate Modern in London.
Professor of Dance, Associate Vice Chancellor for Research, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign; choreographer of Virago-Man, in the 2017 BAM Next Wave Series and currently touring.
Artist, NY; best known for detailed paintings of birds, plants, and transparent human forms in a combination of unorthodox materials, and for his fantastical reimaginings of the pictures on the front page of the New York Times. Represented by James Cohan Gallery and White Cube in London, with solo exhibitions in New York at the Whitney Museum and the Brooklyn Museum.
UArts BFA '75 (Photography). Professor and Chair of the Department of Photography & Imaging at the Tisch School of the Arts at New York University. She is an artist, photographer, curator, photo historian, and author. She is also recipient of the MacArthur “genius” award, among many other accolades.
Artist, Beijing. One of the leading painters of the first generation of artists to emerge in China after the Cultural Revolution and an artist of global influence.
Professor of Neurobiology and Neuroesthetics at University College London and FMedSci Fellow of the Royal Society
We seek students who have already achieved proficiency in an intellectual pursuit – it could be in any field – such that the candidate is prepared for the dissertation stage of a rigorous but out of the box Ph.D. Our students will typically have found themselves wanting to transcend the disciplinary limits of their training with an interdisciplinary project. We will be looking for projects that may not easily fit into programs elsewhere.
Along with an application form collecting contact information, education history, the names of three references, and the non-refundable $50 application fee, applicants must also submit:
- Official Transcripts from all colleges or universities you have attended.
- Personal Statement (maximum 300 words) describing what led to your interest in pursuing a Ph.D. of this kind.
- Preparation for the Dissertation Level (maximum 300 words) describing prior training that supports the dissertation stage of a Ph.D. – degrees, coursework and people with whom you've studied.
- Work Experience (maximum 300 words) describing the work experience that has prepared you to undertake this dissertation.
- Project Statement (maximum 3,000 words) outlining your interests and answering the question, "what do you want to explore?" Include books, articles, bodies of work, or other influences.
- Proposed Advisors (maximum 300 words) or the kind of advisors with whom you might ideally like to work. Your committee need not be UArts faculty, and will be tailored for you.
- Full Resume that best represents your training and achievements, which may include degrees, publications, and reviews.
- Three Letters of Recommendation are required to address an applicant’s commitment and preparation for their project proposal. The name and email address of each referee must be included on the application. Referees should send the confidential letters directly to the admissions committee for the Ph.D.
- International Applicants must demonstrate fluency in spoken and written English as a requirement for this program.
We are currently accepting applications for 2019. The deadline to apply is November 15, 2018. All application materials, including transcripts and letters of recommendation, should be received by this deadline. Applicants may be asked to present their ideas and negotiate a preliminary plan for their project in an interview with members of the admissions committee. Within two weeks of acceptance a non-refundable deposit of $1,000 (to be applied to the first-year tuition) will be required to hold the place. In exceptional cases, this fee may be waived. Late applications will be accepted space permitting, on a case-by-case basis.
The Ph.D. program is pending approval by the Middle States Commission on Higher Education.
Tuition for the summer Arts Immersion is $6,000 and qualified students will be permitted on a space available basis to take this course separately from the dissertation supervision program. Those not intending to go on to the Ph.D. need not complete the dissertation proposal on the application form. Those considering going on to the Ph.D. are advised to complete the application for both parts to hold a space for the upcoming fall; late decisions may result in a year’s delay even if accepted into the program if the cohort is full.
Tuition for the dissertation supervision phase of the program is $44,800 a year. This will cover the cost of hiring top experts from around the world for dissertation committees and administering the winter and second summer seminars. This fee includes all tuition in residence for January and the 2nd year summer program, but it does not include housing. Some fellowships, up to full tuition, will be awarded and all students requesting fellowship must fill out a financial need form. Fellowships will be awarded based on a combination of both merit and need."
Applicants will be notified in their admissions letter if they are awarded a fellowship. The University does not offer assistantships and fellowship funding from the university is limited. If eligible, students who complete the FAFSA may receive an offer of $20,500 in Federal Direct Unsubsidized loans. You can apply to borrow additional funds to cover your costs in the form of a Federal Direct Graduate PLUS loan or private educational loans. All students are strongly encouraged to seek fellowships from external sources in the forms of scholarships, grants, and fellowships from foundations and corporations. The Office of Student Financial Services at the University of the Arts can assist you in starting your funding search.
Please notify us if you have an outside company or agency that will be assisting with funding your degree. This will not disqualify you from being considered for University funds but will allow us to facilitate payment processing. As the majority of work is done remotely in this program students are not eligible for university health insurance."
Contact the program online.
Housing Options While in Residence
We encourage students to find housing within walking distance of the University of the Arts on airbnb or other websites. Typically this should be around $200 a week. We have reserved several good airbnb apartments for the summer session and students interested in those or needing assistance finding other ones should contact our office by email: firstname.lastname@example.org
The 2019 Calendar
A two-week residency is held during the first summer of the program to offer an intensive Arts Immersion course and several days of seminars. Dates for the 2019 summer residency will be announced in fall 2018.
University Professor, University of the Arts
Director of The Ph.D.
Jonathan Fineberg is University Professor at The University of the Arts in Philadelphia. He is the author of Art Since 1940: Strategies of Being the most widely read survey of postwar art and co-creator (with John Carlin) of Imagining America: Icons of 20th Century American Art, the award winning PBS television documentary of 2005. He is the author of some 30 books and catalogs on modern art, including: Christo and Jeanne-Claude: On the Way to the Gates (Yale & Metropolitan Museum of Art, NY); The Innocent Eye: Children's Art and the Modern Artist (Princeton); When We Were Young: New Perspectives on the Art of the Child (University of California Press and The Phillips Collection, Washington DC); and most recently Modern Art at the Border of Mind and Brain (University of Nebraska Press, 2015). He is the Edward William and Jane Marr Gutgsell Professor of Art History Emeritus at the University of Illinois and a Trustee Emeritus of The Phillips Collection in Washington D.C., where he was founding Director of the Center for the Study of Modern Art. He earned his B.A. and Ph.D. from Harvard University, an M.A. from the Courtauld Institute of Art in London, and studied psychoanalysis at the Boston and Western New England Psychoanalytic Institutes. He has curated more than a dozen museum exhibitions, taught at Yale and at Illinois, and as a visitor at Harvard, Columbia, University of California, and elsewhere. His awards include the Pulitzer Fellowship in Critical Writing, the NEA Art Critic's Fellowship, fellowships from the Dedalus Foundation, the Japan Foundation, the ACLS, the American Philosophical Society, and the College Art Association’s Award for Distinguished Teaching in the History of Art.